Are Readers To Blame? On Actively Reading Diverse.

Disclaimer: I thought I would put this here because I assume certain people are going to have a problem with this post – I am in no way telling you what you should and shouldn’t read. Honestly, read whatever the hell you want to. However, give diverse books a go. 

A lot of the discourse surrounding diversity in books has been focused on authors and publishers, and for good reason too – when authors fail to include diversity in their books, and publishers promote and hype said books, teens are less likely to branch out and read diversely.

However, confining to this mentality makes it too easy to continuously blame the book industry and deny any fault that lies on ourselves as readers. Yes, advocate for diversity and yes, support the #WeNeedDiverseBooks movement (because they are both massively important) but also remember, reading diversely starts with you. Whilst it may seem like you’re sometimes screaming into a vortex and can’t possibly change what other people read – you need to remember that you can always change what you read and this is what needs to ground you.

During the month of December, I have been reading exclusively diverse books and I must say – it’s been an eye-opener. I have been introduced to a whole new world of diverse and Own Voices books that I was previously unaware of and I am so excited to read them all. However, there are still a large number of people who continuously advocate against diversity in literature and it is these voices that are harmful to the book community. Because I want to do my part to encourage people to read diverse and reiterate the importance of diverse stories, today I’m going to be dissecting some of the arguments I’ve seen readers use to justify why they don’t read diversely and why I think they really should. 


diversebooksgoodbooks.jpg


I think people are under the impression that the only reason people pick up diverse books is because, well, they’re diverse. I’ve often heard readers exclaim that they don’t read books because they are “diverse”, but instead because they have a good plot or story. Why is it that these two concepts are mutually exclusive? The majority of the diverse books I have read this year have been 4 stars or above and often have overall Goodreads rating that reflect the same. Diverse books aren’t rated highly merely because they are diverse – they are rated highly because they are genuinely amazing. Personally, diverse characters will often lead me to enjoy a book more – not for the inherent fact that the book is diverse but because these diverse characters often add a dimension and realness to the story that non-diverse books lack.

Still, diverse books are still considered inferior to non-diverse books, and a major contributor to this is that they just aren’t hyped enough (which automatically leads to the assumption that they are of poorer quality). This speaks to a deeper trend in the book community where people generally fall into reading patterns, choosing to pick up the book that is hyped up the most or talked about the most by bloggers/booktubers/bookstagrammers rather than the one that is relatively unknown. When these books all feature the same non-diverse characters or are written by non-marginalised authors, persuading readers to buy diverse is much harder (especially in countries where access to lesser-known books is rare). I know it is so tempting to go on Bookstagram, scroll through your feed and just buy the book that appears the most. I know that when a book gets over 10,000 5-star reviews, you’re going to pick it up whether it’s diverse or not. But actively reading diverse is not the same as exclusively reading diverse.  A commitment to read diverse is not the same as a commitment to ignore non-diverse books – it is merely a commitment to make an effort to read books by and about marginalised people (and honestly, you’ll be surprised by how many 5-star books you read as a result) along with your current TBR.


changingbook.jpg


I get it, reluctance to change is part of being human. But actively fighting against the change that makes the book community more inclusive to all its members? Nah, you aren’t getting any sympathy for that one. Some readers are against reading diverse because they believe that the “diversity movement” has changed the book community into something it they’d rather it wouldn’t be. This mindset that the book community is “just not the same anymore” is a pretty common one amongst the privileged. It is mindset that is okay with erasing all the hard work that the book community has done so far is getting marginalised voices to be heard.

You know what, fine – let’s go back a few years to when #WeNeedDiverseBooks wasn’t a movement, back to when diversity wasn’t a focus for change in the book community. Actually no, why stop there? Let’s go back 30 years when LGBTQ+ individuals were actively persecuted and were afraid to be their true selves in public. Let’s go back even further, back to the White Australia Policy, back to Segregation, back to when invasive and devastating procedures were used to “cure” those living with Mental Illness. Do you understand how harmful this notion and this fear of change is?

Yes, the book community could do better. It can always do better. But dismissing the validity and importance of diverse books and diverse authors because you don’t appreciate the way in which discourse is held or the way in which it is changing the community? Find a better reason. Oh wait, there isn’t one.


don'tseecolour.jpg


One of the most aggravating arguments I have heard as a justification for not reading diversely is that readers don’t see any point in focusing on a person’s skin tone. Instead, they value “diversity of thought” or “diversity of opinion” and they just generally “don’t see colour/sexuality/gender identity/disabilities”.

For the people who genuinely don’t know why this is offensive, let me try to explain – people of colour, people from the LGBTQ+ spectrum, disabled people, they’ve already had themselves erased from media, literature and other forms of representation over and over again, time after time, year after year. When you say that you don’t see the colour of a character’s skin when reading a book, or don’t particularly care whether or not a marginalised character is represented – that’s your privilege speaking through. It may not be intentional, and you may not want to be hurtful, but that’s just reality. This is privilege that has been built up upon centuries of White/cishet/able-bodied being the social norm. It’s privilege developed because you’ve never had to struggle to see yourself reflected in your favourite characters. It’s privilege that forms because when you were young and dressing up for the local Book Fair, you could have easily been anyone that you wanted to be.

Although your first choice may be to pick up the NYT bestseller (which may be diverse, but is more likely not because of how society works), make an active choice to pick up a diverse book instead. Make an active choice to read about marginalised experiences in order to take apart and understand your privilege. Make an active choice to use your reading experience for not only enjoyment, but to also become empathetic to other’s lives. Use your voice in the community to raise up the voices of others, voices that may be struggling to be heard.


now what.jpg


There are so many wonderful Own Voices and diverse books that are looked over in favour of others and we, as readers, need to make a conscientious decision to read them. I hope some of you found this post inspiring and pick up a diverse book. If you’re looking for recommendations – I highly suggest checking out the official #WeNeedDiverseBooks site here, or Naz’s wonderful blog @ Read Diverse Books. If you’re looking for some books to add to your TBR for 2017, I have a list of my most anticipated diverse reads here.

Also if you’re in the mood for some further blog hopping, check out these wonderful diverse voices as well – Meleika @ The Aus Library, CW @ Read, Think, Ponder and Aentee @ Read at Midnight.


Until next time, 

happyreadingjananee

Advertisements

16 thoughts on “Are Readers To Blame? On Actively Reading Diverse.

  1. Wendy Chen says:

    Loved your thoughts here, Jananee! I’ve felt strongly about diversity since the beginning of the movement but it was also only recently that I actively began prioritising diverse books – which I’ve really benefitted from – but it’s also a useful heuristic to sort my TBR with, and a reminder of the books and authors who need my support the most. As a part-time English/Writing tutor I also aim to put diverse books, often those looking at prejudice, into the hands of my students, especially the younger ones. Just giving that as an example because I 100% agree that everyone needs to play a part, not only the writers and publishers.
    Thanks for this!

    Liked by 1 person

    • headinherbooks says:

      Thanks for the lovely comment Wendy 😘I think it’s absolutely great that you’re trying to get diverse books into the hands of your students! Hopefully they’ll be able to learn a little and see themselves reflected in the stories they read ☺️

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Jordyn @ Jordz the Bibliophile says:

    Such a fantastic post!! I honestly don’t understand why people don’t want the book community to change. News flash, nothing can stay the same. If the book community doesn’t evolve and change as the rest of the world becomes more progressive, then what are we? I’ve honestly learned so much about diversity from people like you, so thank you so much for that! You’re awesome!!

    Okay, quick off-topic question: what website/app do you use to make your graphics? Cause your feature image and graphics are AMAZING ❤

    Liked by 1 person

    • headinherbooks says:

      Awwww thank you Jordyn! The community can be so adverse to change sometimes that they don’t recognise the good it’s doing. (I use creative market for my graphics and photoshop to put them together! Thank you for your lovely comment 💕)

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Green Tea & Paperbacks says:

    I loved this! I wasn’t really apart of the book community before #weneeddiversebooks became a movement, but I wouldn’t want it any other way. This is such an important thing.I remember when I first read a book about someone dealing with anxiety, and I ended up crying because I knew I wasn’t alone. Everyone deserves to know they’re not alone, and books are the perfect way to do that. I’ve made it my goal to have at least 60% of the books I read in 2017 be diverse 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    • headinherbooks says:

      Awwww I totally understand how it feels to find that character or book that you relate to! It’s the same way I feel about Inej from Six Of Crows 💕 I have definitely also made it a goal to read more diversely next year! Good luck 😘

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Tiana says:

    This is so important! I myself haven’t been able to read as many diverse books as I would like and I think that every culture/sexuality/mental&physicaldisability needs to be written/read about. I loved this beautiful post. Please continue to raise your words on this topic. We need more people like you in the bookish community.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Emily @ Loony Literate says:

    YES TO THIS. For society and culture in year 12 I did my major research project on diversity in YA and it was so shocking to hear some of the stats. One was like…90% of NYT bestselling authors are white. Which is mind-blowing. I used to read mainly non-diverse books when I first started reading YA (stuff like John Green, Sarah Dessen etc.) but honestly, many of my favourite books now are diverse. When I think of things like Tiny Pretty Things, Aristotle and Dante, To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before, Radio Silence…the world is so much more colourful when we’re representing all the people in it ❤

    AWESOME POST, LOVELY 🙂 And also the "not seeing colour" thing is such bullshit lmao.

    Liked by 1 person

    • headinherbooks says:

      OMG THAT IS SUCH A COOL PIP! I was too scared to take S&C because of the major project 😂 But yeah, when you start to think about it, the stats are pretty ridiculous :/ But I’m glad that a lot more people are actively reading diverse now then they did before!

      Like

    • areaderslives says:

      I completely agree with you. Some of the statistics are horrifying and it is nice to see that people are beginning to read more diverse books and writers are making an effort to represent all kinds of people.But I don’t think the “I don’t see colour” thing is bullshit. I can’t speak for everyone but I can speak for myself.When I say Inej Ghafa from SoC is my favourite character it’s not because she has the same skin colour as me it’s because she is a good human being who can show compassion despite the whole world being nothing less than terrible to her. I genuinely don’t care what colour you are, I would still treat you the same. I know a lot people use this as an excuse to shun the importance of diversity but that doesn’t mean it’s bullshit. It’s bullshit only when people use it for the wrong reasons. I think it’s important that we don’t see colour that doesn’t mean I’m against representation.
      Sorry for the long rant but I hope you understand what I’m trying to say.

      Like

      • headinherbooks says:

        It’s great that you don’t discriminate on colour and that that’s what “I don’t see colour means to you”. However, the point is that people don’t want you to disregard the colour of their skin but instead embrace it – saying “I don’t see colour” is too easily interpreted as the colour of a characters skin not having any importance, which it absolutely does. Not because you are going to judge them differently based on it but because it the sort of representation that so many readers need. You reference Inej and she is one of my favourite characters as well. For her personality but also because she’s brown – it is so vital that I can see characters like myself in fiction because it’s the the representation I have craved all my life. I hope this helps explain where we are coming from ☺️

        Like

      • areaderslives says:

        I totally get where you’re coming from. Readers would obviously want characters like them in the books they read. I guess it doesn’t matter to me since I’m more of a “I’m a brain the rest of me is mere appendix” person. That being said I would love to see more representation for brown people especially Indians.For being one of the most populated countries we sure are pretty absent in the global literature scenario. Padma Padma and Parvati just being there in HP used to give me hope. If they had been more developed I’m certain I would have enjoyed the series much more.

        Like

      • areaderslives says:

        I totally get where you’re coming from. Readers would obviously want characters like them in the books they read. I guess I’m just more of a “I’m a brain the rest of me is mere appendix” person so it doesn’t matter to me much. That being said I would love to see more representation of brown people especially Indians.For being one of the most populated countries we sure are pretty absent in the global literature scenario. Padma and Parvati just being there in HP used to give me hope. If they had been more developed I’m certain I would have enjoyed the series much more.
        Great post by the way.You’re probably one of the few people who seem civil on this subject and wants people to accept it willingly instead of trying to shove it down everyone’s throat.

        Liked by 1 person

      • headinherbooks says:

        Yeah Padma and Parvati were super disregarded in HP and it makes me sad sometimes. I think people who are trying to “force it down your throat” are just fed up with fighting for diversity all their lives and probably just didn’t expect it to be so hard for the book community to accept something that brings much needed change ☺️

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s